Home
1 Stanza Poem
Poem

To A Poet (Poem by William Butler Yeats)

In "To a Poet," William Butler Yeats offers a clever and thought-provoking commentary on the act of praising the work of other poets.
the Old Poems

To A Poet, Who Would Have Me Praise Certain Bad Poets, Imitators of His and Mine
By William Butler Yeats


You say, as I have often given tongue
In praise of what another’s said or sung,
’Twere politic to do the like by these;
But was there ever dog that praised his fleas?

Poem Analysis:

William Butler Yeats' poem "To a Poet" is a concise and witty piece that reflects on the act of praising or celebrating the work of other poets. Through a metaphor involving a dog and fleas, the poem offers commentary on the nature of criticism, praise, and individual artistic expression.

Themes:

  1. Criticism and Praise: The central theme of the poem revolves around the idea of criticizing or praising the work of other poets. It questions the authenticity of praise when it is done out of a sense of obligation or politeness rather than genuine admiration.
  2. Artistic Integrity: The poem indirectly touches upon the notion of artistic integrity. It suggests that true poets and artists should prioritize their creative freedom and authenticity over conforming to societal expectations or offering praise for the sake of it.

Structure:

The poem is exceptionally brief, consisting of only four lines. It is written in a single quatrain with a simple AABB rhyme scheme. This concise structure mirrors the poem's succinct and pointed message.

Analysis:

  1. The Metaphor of the Dog and Fleas: The poem employs a metaphor comparing poets to dogs and their works to fleas. The speaker acknowledges that they have often praised the works of others, much like a dog acknowledging the presence of fleas. However, the analogy suggests that such praise may be obligatory or automatic, akin to a dog merely acknowledging the existence of fleas on its fur.
  2. Questioning the Sincerity of Praise: The central question posed in the poem challenges the sincerity of praise. The speaker questions whether it is "politic" or strategic to praise the works of other poets. The use of the word "politic" implies that such praise may be driven by social or political considerations rather than genuine admiration.
  3. Artistic Independence: The poem subtly advocates for artistic independence and authenticity. It implies that poets should not feel compelled to praise the works of their peers simply because it is expected. Instead, they should prioritize their own creative voices and individual expressions.
  4. Irony and Wit: Yeats' poem is characterized by its irony and wit. The speaker's use of the dog and fleas metaphor adds humor to the poem while conveying a deeper message about the nature of praise in the artistic world.
  5. Universal Theme: While the poem is directed toward a fellow poet, its theme of questioning the authenticity of praise is universal. It invites readers to reflect on the nature of praise, criticism, and the sincerity of their own expressions of admiration.

In "To a Poet," William Butler Yeats offers a clever and thought-provoking commentary on the act of praising the work of other poets. Through the metaphor of a dog and fleas, he questions the sincerity of such praise when it is done out of obligation rather than genuine admiration. The poem encourages poets to prioritize their artistic authenticity and individual voices over conforming to societal expectations. It is a concise and witty exploration of the complexities of artistic expression and criticism.

© Poetry. All rights reserved.